As of mid-January 2026, the Nigerian insurance industry is at a critical crossroads. A proposal to exempt foreign insurance companies from paying tax on premiums sourced from Nigeria has sparked a heated debate between the federal government and local operators.
While proponents argue that tax breaks for foreign insurers would deepen market penetration, domestic firms warn that it creates a “harmful and unfair” disadvantage during a sensitive period of industry rehabilitation.
1. The Core of the Controversy
The proposal stems from a review of the Nigeria Tax Act 2025 by KPMG Nigeria, which suggested that removing Withholding Tax (WHT) on premiums paid to non-residents would enhance Nigeria’s competitiveness and growth.
-
The KPMG Argument: Exempting overseas insurance premiums could attract global expertise and increase the currently stagnant insurance penetration rate (which hovers around 1.2%).
-
The Government’s Rebuttal: The Presidential Fiscal Policy and Tax Reforms Committee, led by Taiwo Oyedele, formally rejected the proposal on January 10, 2026. The committee argued that exempting foreign firms while local ones pay full tax would be “detrimental” and would “penalize Nigerian insurers in their own market.”
2. Market Impact: “Level Playing Field” at Risk
Local stakeholders, including former executives and the Nigerian Insurers Association (NIA), have expressed deep concern that such an exemption would undermine the hard-won gains of recent reforms.
Key Concerns for Local Operators:
-
Pricing Disadvantage: If foreign firms operate tax-free, they can offer significantly lower premiums, potentially pricing domestic insurers out of large-scale or specialized risks (like Oil & Gas and Aviation).
-
Capital Flight: Critics argue the move could encourage the “externalization” of insurance business, where value is extracted from the Nigerian economy rather than retained.
-
Discouraging Local Investment: At a time when local firms are being asked to inject billions in fresh capital, a tax holiday for foreign competitors is seen as a “market distortion.”
3. The NIIRA 2025 and Recapitalization
The tax debate coincides with the most significant regulatory overhaul in two decades: the Nigerian Insurance Industry Reform Act (NIIRA) 2025.
Under the new Act, NAICOM has set a strict July 30, 2026, deadline for all insurers to meet significantly higher Minimum Capital Requirements (MCR):
| Business Category | New Minimum Capital (2026 Deadline) |
| Life Insurance | ₦10 Billion |
| Non-Life Insurance | ₦15 Billion |
| Composite (Life + Non-Life) | ₦25 Billion |
| Reinsurance | ₦35 Billion |
4. The 2026 Outlook: Consolidation or Expansion?
The industry’s focus for the remainder of 2026 is expected to be on:
-
M&A Activity: Many smaller firms that cannot meet the ₦15–₦25 billion threshold are currently in “concrete negotiations” for mergers or acquisitions to avoid license revocation.
-
Digital Transformation: Moving away from traditional brokerage to digital distribution and micro-insurance to reach the 230 million-strong population.
-
Tax Harmonization: The government is expected to move forward with plans to reduce the standard Corporate Income Tax (CIT) rate from 30% to 25% for all businesses, which may offer more “equitable” relief to the sector than specific exemptions for foreign players.
“You cannot ask local companies to recapitalize and still pay full taxes while foreign firms are given tax holidays to compete for the same risks.” — Alfred Daudu, FSL Insurance Broker
